{
  "schemaVersion": "1.1.0",
  "brand": "Aromitas",
  "title": "Fragrance reference and EcoBase spray calculator data",
  "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
  "fragranceCount": 81,
  "description": "Public formulation reference for the 81 CandleScience fragrances in the Aromitas collection. Purchase and receipt details are excluded.",
  "calculator": {
    "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
    "minimumLoadPercent": 3,
    "maximumLoadPercent": 10,
    "recommendedLoadPercent": 5,
    "premixPercent": 25,
    "distilledWaterPercent": 75,
    "ingredientUnit": "g",
    "percentageBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
    "usFluidOunceMl": 29.5735295625,
    "volumeEstimateDensityGPerMl": 1,
    "volumeEstimateIsApproximate": true,
    "formulaSourceUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/candlescience-ecobase-room-and-linen-spray-calculator/"
  },
  "statusDefinitions": {
    "workingRange": "Overlap of supplier application recommendation, the chosen base normal band and applicable IFRA limits. A development range, not a tested Aromitas production formula.",
    "notRecommended": "Supplier explicitly says not approved for this application. Working min/max are 0; positive IFRA allowance is retained separately.",
    "ifraProhibited": "Applicable IFRA maximum is zero.",
    "belowStandardRange": "A positive screening ceiling lies below the normal band. Working endpoints are null; the ceiling is retained. Does not mean lower-strength formulation is impossible.",
    "unverified": "No applicable verified recipe or compatibility conclusion. Unknown endpoints are null, never zero.",
    "testOnly": "Candidate for R&D, inferred from an adjacent supported format. It has no official car working range."
  },
  "bases": {
    "ecoBaseReedDiffuser": {
      "name": "CandleScience EcoBase Reed Diffuser Base",
      "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
      "normalMinPercent": null,
      "normalMaxPercent": 25,
      "sourceIds": [
        "G01",
        "G02"
      ],
      "notes": "25% is the tutorial target. Individual oil approval, stated range and IFRA 10A govern; no general minimum is invented."
    },
    "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate": {
      "name": "CandleScience EcoBase Room and Linen Spray concentrate",
      "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
      "normalMinPercent": 3,
      "normalMaxPercent": 10,
      "defaultTestPercent": 5,
      "sourceIds": [
        "G03",
        "G04",
        "G11"
      ],
      "notes": "Fragrance percentage is of finished batch weight. For loads 3-10%: premix (base + fragrance) = 25%; distilled water = 75%. Base percentage = 25 minus fragrance percentage."
    },
    "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater": {
      "name": "CandleScience EcoBase Fine Fragrance Base (water-based)",
      "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
      "normalMinPercent": 10,
      "normalMaxPercent": 15,
      "sourceIds": [
        "G05",
        "G12"
      ],
      "notes": "Normal perfume band; lower concentrations are not automatically prohibited. This reference does not cover body or hair mist."
    },
    "ecoBasePerfumeOil": {
      "name": "CandleScience EcoBase Perfume Oil Base (oil-based)",
      "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
      "normalMinPercent": 20,
      "normalMaxPercent": 30,
      "sourceIds": [
        "G06",
        "G12"
      ],
      "notes": "Normal perfume-strength band for localized pulse-point use. Rollerball viscosity requires testing. Lower-strength oil perfume is not automatically prohibited; all-over body oil is a separate application."
    },
    "simplySoyArtisanContainer": {
      "name": "CandleScience SimplySoy Artisan Wax - container candles",
      "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
      "normalMinPercent": null,
      "normalMaxPercent": 10,
      "defaultTestPercent": 6,
      "sourceIds": [
        "G07",
        "G08"
      ],
      "notes": "10% maximum is wax basis. Tealights have a separate 5% maximum. This wax is not a wax-melt/pillar recommendation."
    }
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "G01",
      "title": "EcoBase Reed Diffuser Base",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/reed-diffusers/candlescience-ecobase-diffuser-solution/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G02",
      "title": "How to make a reed diffuser",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/how-to-make-a-reed-diffuser/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G03",
      "title": "Scaling room and linen spray",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/learning/a-beginner-s-guide-to-scaling-room-and-linen-spray/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G04",
      "title": "Room and linen spray calculator",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/candlescience-ecobase-room-and-linen-spray-calculator/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G05",
      "title": "EcoBase Fine Fragrance Base (water-based)",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/candlescience-ecobase-fine-fragrance-base-water-based/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G06",
      "title": "EcoBase Perfume Oil Base (oil-based)",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/candlescience-ecobase-perfume-oil-base-oil-based/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G07",
      "title": "SimplySoy Artisan Wax",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/wax/candlescience-simplysoy-artisan-wax/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G08",
      "title": "SimplySoy Artisan lab notes",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/lab-notes-candlescience-simplysoy-artisan-wax/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G09",
      "title": "How to use the IFRA certificate",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/learning/how-to-use-the-ifra-certificate/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G10",
      "title": "IFRA 51st Amendment guidance, product categories",
      "url": "https://ifrafragrance.org/docs/default-source/51st-amendment/ifra-51st-amendment---guidance-for-the-use-of-ifra-standards.pdf",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G11",
      "title": "EcoBase Room and Linen Spray concentrate",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/candlescience-ecobase-room-and-linen-spray/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G12",
      "title": "Fine Fragrance Tutorial",
      "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/Fine%20Fragrance%20Tutorial.pdf",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "G13",
      "title": "Fragrance and Blending Calculator",
      "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance-blending-calculator/",
      "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
    }
  ],
  "fragrances": [
    {
      "id": "alchemy",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Alchemy",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/alchemy-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 24.24,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 24.24%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 13,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 13.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Alchemy%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2026-04-27",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 24.24,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 13,
          "10B": 28,
          "11B": 0.84
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F01",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 13,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 13,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 24.24,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 24.24,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 24.24,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 24.24,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": 10,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 13,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/alchemy-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Alchemy%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-04-27"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "amber-and-driftwood",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Amber and Driftwood",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/amber-and-driftwood-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 15.2,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 15.2%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Amber%20and%20Driftwood%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-20",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 15.23,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 9.98,
          "10B": 63.07,
          "11B": 0.36
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F02",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 63.07,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 9.98,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 9.98,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 9.98,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 9.98,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.23,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.23,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15.2,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 15.2% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.98,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/amber-and-driftwood-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Amber%20and%20Driftwood%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-20"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "amber-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Amber Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/amber-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Amber%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2025-09-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 5.6,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 5.6,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 25.6,
          "5B": 16.8,
          "5C": 25.6,
          "5D": 5.6,
          "7A": 33.5,
          "7B": 33.5,
          "10A": 61.06,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 5.6,
          "11B": 5.6
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F03",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 61.06,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 61.06,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 61.06,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 61.06,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/amber-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Amber%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-09-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "amber-noir",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Amber Noir",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/amber-noir-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 5,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 5.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 5,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 5.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 12.8,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 12.8%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Amber%20Noir%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-21",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 12.88,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 5.09,
          "10B": 32.2,
          "11B": 0.18
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F04",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.09,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 32.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.09,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 5.09,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 5.09,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.09,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 5.09,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 5.09,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 12.88,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 12.8,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 12.8,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 12.88,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 12.8,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 12.8% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.09,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/amber-noir-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Amber%20Noir%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-21"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "apple-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Apple Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/apple-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 14.3,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 14.3%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Apple%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2025-07-11",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 0.76,
          "4": 14.33,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 1.5,
          "9": 28,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 3.66,
          "5B": 3.66,
          "5C": 3.66,
          "5D": 2.8,
          "7A": 29.33,
          "7B": 29.33,
          "10A": 98,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 2.8,
          "11B": 2.8
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F05",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.33,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 14.3,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 14.3,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.33,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 14.3,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 14.3% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 98,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/apple-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Apple%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-07-11"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "aquatic-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Aquatic Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/aquatic-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Aquatic%20Element%20IFRA%2051%202024.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-09-16",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 9.03,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 13.54,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 41.29,
          "5B": 41.29,
          "5C": 41.29,
          "5D": 13.54,
          "7A": 55.48,
          "7B": 55.48,
          "10A": 48.38,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 13.54,
          "11B": 13.54
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F06",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48.38,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48.38,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48.38,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48.38,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/aquatic-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Aquatic%20Element%20IFRA%2051%202024.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-09-16"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "arctic-ivy",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Arctic Ivy",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/arctic-ivy-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Arctic%20Ivy%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2024-05-23",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 29.6,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 7.1,
          "10B": 22.4,
          "11B": 0.7
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F07",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.1,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 22.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.1,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.1,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.1,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.1,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.1,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.1,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 29.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 29.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.1,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/arctic-ivy-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Arctic%20Ivy%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-05-23"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "arugula-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Arugula Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/arugula-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Arugula%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2025-07-11",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 2.8,
          "4": 50,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 1.68,
          "9": 26,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 12.8,
          "5B": 5,
          "5C": 7.6,
          "5D": 1.68,
          "7A": 6.2,
          "7B": 6.2,
          "10A": 26,
          "10B": 56,
          "11A": 1.68,
          "11B": 1.68
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F08",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 26,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 56,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 26,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 26,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 50,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 50,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 26,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/arugula-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Arugula%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-07-11"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "azura",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Azura",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/azura-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 5,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 5.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Azura%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2026-04-27",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11B": 24.44
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F09",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": 10,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/azura-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Azura%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-04-27"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "baking-spices-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Baking Spices Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/baking-spices-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 2.9,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 2.9%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2.9,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.9%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Baking%20Spices%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 0.08,
          "4": 1.51,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.08,
          "9": 2.96,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 0.38,
          "5B": 0.25,
          "5C": 0.38,
          "5D": 0.08,
          "7A": 1.03,
          "7B": 1.03,
          "10A": 2.96,
          "10B": 10.9,
          "11A": 0.08,
          "11B": 0.08
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F10",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.96,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.9,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.96,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.96,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.96% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.96,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.96,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.96% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 1.51,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 1.51,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.96,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/baking-spices-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Baking%20Spices%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "baltic-dew",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Baltic Dew",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/baltic-dew-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Baltic%20Dew%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2024-12-05",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 81.51,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 31.57,
          "10B": 68,
          "11B": 2.04
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F11",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 31.57,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 68,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 31.57,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 31.57,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 81.51,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 81.51,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 31.57,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/baltic-dew-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Baltic%20Dew%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-12-05"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "basil-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Basil Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/basil-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 4.4,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 4.4%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Basil%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 2.7,
          "4": 27.4,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.4,
          "9": 8.2,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 4.4,
          "5B": 1.2,
          "5C": 1.2,
          "5D": 0.4,
          "7A": 1.2,
          "7B": 1.2,
          "10A": 1.8,
          "10B": 4.4,
          "11A": 0.4,
          "11B": 0.4
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F12",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 1.8,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 4.4,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 4.4,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 1.8,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 1.8,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 1.8% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 1.8,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 1.8,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 1.8% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 27.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 27.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 1.8,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/basil-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Basil%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "bergamot-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Bergamot Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/bergamot-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 18.8,
          "sourceText": "up to 18.8%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Bergamot%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 1.5,
          "4": 28.24,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.69,
          "9": 18.84,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 7.06,
          "5B": 2.08,
          "5C": 7.06,
          "5D": 0.69,
          "7A": 4.06,
          "7B": 4.06,
          "10A": 18.84,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 0.69,
          "11B": 0.69
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F13",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18.84,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 18.8,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 18.8,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18.84,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18.84,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 28.24,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 28.24,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18.84,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 18.8,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/bergamot-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Bergamot%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "black-coral-and-moss",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Black Coral and Moss",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/black-coral-and-moss-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 5.2,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 5.2%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 5.2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 5.2%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Black%20Coral%20and%20Moss%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-21",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 34.34,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 5.2,
          "10B": 11.2,
          "11B": 0.33
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F14",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 11.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 5.2,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 5.2,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 5.2,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 5.2,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 34.34,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 34.34,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.2,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/black-coral-and-moss-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Black%20Coral%20and%20Moss%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-21"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "black-currant-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Black Currant Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/black-currant-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 17.1,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 17.1%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Black%20Currant%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2025-07-11",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 0.91,
          "4": 17.14,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 1.79,
          "9": 33.49,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 4.38,
          "5B": 4.38,
          "5C": 4.38,
          "5D": 2.25,
          "7A": 20.5,
          "7B": 20.5,
          "10A": 50,
          "10B": 50,
          "11A": 2.25,
          "11B": 2.25
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F15",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 50,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 50,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 50,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 50,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 17.14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 17.14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 17.1,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 17.1% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 50,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/black-currant-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Black%20Currant%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-07-11"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "black-raspberry-vanilla",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Black Raspberry Vanilla",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/black-raspberry-vanilla-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 4.1,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 4.1%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 4.1,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 4.1%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Black%20Raspberry%20Vanilla%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-21",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 9.27,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 4.15,
          "10B": 13.14,
          "11B": 0.15
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F16",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.15,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13.14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.15,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 4.15,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 4.15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.15,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 4.15,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 4.15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.27,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.27,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.15,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/black-raspberry-vanilla-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Black%20Raspberry%20Vanilla%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-21"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "black-sea",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Black Sea",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/black-sea-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 3.7,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 3.7%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 3.7,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 3.7%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 9.3,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 9.3%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Black%20Sea%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-21",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 9.31,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 3.68,
          "10B": 23.28,
          "11B": 0.13
        }
      },
      "notes": [
        "Perfume supplier range 5-9.3% is below the water-based EcoBase perfume range 10-15% and oil-based perfume range 20-30%; retain as belowStandardRange, not an IFRA prohibition."
      ],
      "referenceId": "F17",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.68,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 23.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.68,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 3.68,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 3.68,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.68,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 3.68,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 3.68,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.31,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 9.3,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 9.3% is below the 10% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.31,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 9.3,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 9.3% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.68,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/black-sea-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Black%20Sea%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-21"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "black-violet-and-saffron",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Black Violet and Saffron",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/black-violet-and-saffron-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 14.2,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 14.2%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 14.2,
          "sourceText": "up to 14.2%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Black%20Violet%20and%20Saffron%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-18",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 14.28,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 14.28,
          "10B": 14.28,
          "11B": 0.64
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F18",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 14.2,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 14.2,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 14.2,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 14.2,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 14.2,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 14.2% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.28,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 14.2,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/black-violet-and-saffron-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Black%20Violet%20and%20Saffron%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-18"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "bohemian-rose",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Bohemian Rose",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/bohemian-rose-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 10.5,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 10.5%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 15.7,
          "sourceText": "up to 15.7%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Bohemian%20Rose%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2023-12-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 10.5,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 15.7,
          "10B": 73.5,
          "11B": 0.5
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F19",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.7,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15.7,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15.7,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 73.5,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.7,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.7,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.5,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10.5,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10.5,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.5,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10.5,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 10.5% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.7,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 15.7,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/bohemian-rose-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Bohemian%20Rose%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2023-12-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "campfire-marshmallow",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Campfire Marshmallow",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/campfire-marshmallow-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 21.2,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 21.2%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 18.8,
          "sourceText": "up to 18.8%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Campfire%20Marshmallow%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2025-09-04",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 21.36,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 18.8,
          "10B": 72.64,
          "11B": 0.48
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F20",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18.8,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 18.8,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 18.8,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 72.64,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18.8,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18.8,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 21.36,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 21.36,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 21.2,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 21.2,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18.8,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 18.8,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/campfire-marshmallow-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Campfire%20Marshmallow%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-09-04"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "cardamom-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Cardamom Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/cardamom-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Cardamom%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 23.02,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 31.33,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 100,
          "5B": 94.01,
          "5C": 100,
          "5D": 31.33,
          "7A": 94.01,
          "7B": 94.01,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 31.33,
          "11B": 31.33
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F21",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/cardamom-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Cardamom%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "cedar-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Cedar Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/cedar-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Cedar%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 5.59,
          "4": 99.98,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 8.39,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 25.59,
          "5B": 25.59,
          "5C": 25.59,
          "5D": 8.39,
          "7A": 30.5,
          "7B": 30.5,
          "10A": 30.5,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 8.39,
          "11B": 8.39
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F22",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 30.5,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 30.5,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 30.5,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 99.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 99.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 30.5,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/cedar-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Cedar%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "cherry-eclipse",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Cherry Eclipse",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/cherry-eclipse-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 1,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 1.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Cherry%20Eclipse%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2024-12-05",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 3.9,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 7.7,
          "10B": 28.5,
          "11B": 1.2
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F23",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.7,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 28.5,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.7,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.7,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.7,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.7,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.7,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.7,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.9,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.9,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.7,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/cherry-eclipse-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Cherry%20Eclipse%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-12-05"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "chocolate-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Chocolate Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/chocolate-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Chocolate%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 100,
          "2": 100,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 100,
          "8": 100,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 100,
          "5B": 100,
          "5C": 100,
          "5D": 100,
          "7A": 100,
          "7B": 100,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 100,
          "11B": 100
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F24",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/chocolate-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Chocolate%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "cinnamon-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Cinnamon Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/cinnamon-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 0.5,
          "sourceText": "up to 0.5%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Cinnamon%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 0.01,
          "4": 0.27,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.01,
          "9": 0.54,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 0.07,
          "5B": 0.04,
          "5C": 0.07,
          "5D": 0.01,
          "7A": 0.18,
          "7B": 0.18,
          "10A": 0.54,
          "10B": 2,
          "11A": 0.01,
          "11B": 0.01
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F25",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 0.54,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 0.54,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0.54,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 0.54% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 0.54,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0.54,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 0.54% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 0.27,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 0.27,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 0.54,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/cinnamon-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Cinnamon%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "citronella-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Citronella Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/citronella-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 14,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 14.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Citronella-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2026-05-05",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 1.62,
          "4": 4.97,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.17,
          "9": 14.21,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 3.35,
          "5B": 0.51,
          "5C": 1.01,
          "5D": 0.17,
          "7A": 0.78,
          "7B": 0.78,
          "10A": 14.21,
          "10B": 23.34,
          "11A": 0.17,
          "11B": 0.17
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F26",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.21,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 14,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 14,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 23.34,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.21,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.21,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.97,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.97,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.21,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": 10,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 14,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/citronella-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Citronella-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-05-05"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "coastal-cottage",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Coastal Cottage",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/coastal-cottage-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 19,
          "sourceText": "up to 19.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Coastal%20Cottage%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2025-10-20",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 48,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 19,
          "10B": 100,
          "11B": 0.7
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F27",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 19,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 19,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 19,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/coastal-cottage-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Coastal%20Cottage%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-10-20"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "coconut-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Coconut Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/coconut-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 10.4,
          "sourceText": "up to 10.4%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Coconut%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 1.6,
          "4": 30,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.7,
          "9": 10.4,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 7.6,
          "5B": 2.2,
          "5C": 3.2,
          "5D": 0.7,
          "7A": 3.6,
          "7B": 3.6,
          "10A": 10.4,
          "10B": 32,
          "11A": 0.7,
          "11B": 0.7
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F28",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10.4,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10.4,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 32,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 30,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 30,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.4,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 10.4,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/coconut-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Coconut%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "coconut-soleil",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Coconut Soleil",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/coconut-soleil-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 15.1,
          "sourceText": "up to 15.1%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Coconut%20Soleil%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-18",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 29.33,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 15.16,
          "10B": 80,
          "11B": 0.55
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F29",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.16,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15.1,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15.1,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 80,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.16,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.16,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 29.33,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 29.33,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.16,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 15.1,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/coconut-soleil-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Coconut%20Soleil%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-18"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "coffee-bean-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Coffee Bean Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/coffee-bean-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 14,
          "sourceText": "up to 14.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Coffee-Bean-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2026-05-05",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 0.4,
          "4": 7.14,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.4,
          "9": 14,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 1.82,
          "5B": 1.2,
          "5C": 1.82,
          "5D": 0.4,
          "7A": 4.85,
          "7B": 4.85,
          "10A": 14,
          "10B": 51.42,
          "11A": 0.4,
          "11B": 0.4
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F30",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 14,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 14,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 51.42,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 14,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/coffee-bean-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Coffee-Bean-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-05-05"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "condensed-milk-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Condensed Milk Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/condensed-milk-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 19.21,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 19.21%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Condensed-Milk-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2026-05-05",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 4.66,
          "4": 19.21,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.28,
          "9": 7.6,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 17.2,
          "5B": 0.84,
          "5C": 3.32,
          "5D": 0.28,
          "7A": 1.64,
          "7B": 1.64,
          "10A": 7.6,
          "10B": 48.02,
          "11A": 0.28,
          "11B": 0.28
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F31",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48.02,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.6,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.6,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.6,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.6,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19.21,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19.21,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 19.21,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 19.21% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.6,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/condensed-milk-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Condensed-Milk-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-05-05"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "cucumber-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Cucumber Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/cucumber-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 21.4,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 21.4%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Cucumber%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 1.14,
          "4": 21.48,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 2.25,
          "9": 41.87,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 5.44,
          "5B": 5.44,
          "5C": 5.44,
          "5D": 5.44,
          "7A": 25.33,
          "7B": 25.33,
          "10A": 80,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 6.66,
          "11B": 6.66
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F32",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 80,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 80,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 80,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 21.48,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 21.48,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 21.4,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 21.4,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 80,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/cucumber-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Cucumber%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "dragons-blood",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Dragon's Blood",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/dragons-blood-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 2.9,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 2.9%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2.9,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.9%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 9.2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 9.2%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Dragons%20Blood%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-20",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 7.54,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 2.98,
          "10B": 8.96,
          "11B": 0.1
        }
      },
      "notes": [
        "Supplier page room-spray maximum 9.2% exceeds linked IFRA Category 10B maximum 8.96%. Apply the stricter certificate cap; page/certificate mismatch requires attention."
      ],
      "referenceId": "F33",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 8.96,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 8.96,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 8.96,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.98,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.98% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.98,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.98% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.54,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.54,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.98,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/dragons-blood-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Dragons%20Blood%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-20"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "eucalyptus-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Eucalyptus Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/eucalyptus-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Eucalyptus-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2026-05-05",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 100,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 100,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 100,
          "5B": 100,
          "5C": 100,
          "5D": 100,
          "7A": 100,
          "7B": 100,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 100,
          "11B": 100
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F34",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": 10,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/eucalyptus-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Eucalyptus-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-05-05"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "fig-leaf-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Fig Leaf Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/fig-leaf-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 5.7,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 5.7%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 5.7,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 5.7%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 23.7,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 23.7%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Fig%20Leaf%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2025-07-11",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 3.5,
          "4": 23.75,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.62,
          "9": 5.75,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 11.25,
          "5B": 1.9,
          "5C": 1.9,
          "5D": 0.62,
          "7A": 1.9,
          "7B": 1.9,
          "10A": 5.75,
          "10B": 18,
          "11A": 0.62,
          "11B": 0.62
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F35",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 5.75,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 5.75,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 5.75,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 5.75,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 23.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 23.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 23.7,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 23.7,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.75,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/fig-leaf-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Fig%20Leaf%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-07-11"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "fireside",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Fireside",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/fireside-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 2.3,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 2.3%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2.3,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.3%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Fireside%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-19",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 6.02,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 2.38,
          "10B": 15.05,
          "11B": 0.08
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F36",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.38,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 15.05,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.38,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.38,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.38% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.38,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.38,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.38% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 6.02,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 6.02,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.38,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/fireside-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Fireside%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-19"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "fleurette",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Fleurette",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/fleurette-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Fleurette%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2026-04-27",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11B": 8.4
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F37",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": 10,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/fleurette-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Fleurette%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-04-27"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "fog-and-fern",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Fog and Fern",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/fog-and-fern-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Fog%20and%20Fern%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2024-03-08",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 25,
          "10B": 68.7,
          "11B": 1.9
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F38",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 68.7,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/fog-and-fern-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Fog%20and%20Fern%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-03-08"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "glacier-lily",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Glacier Lily",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/glacier-lily-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Glacier%20Lily%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2024-05-24",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 9.13,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 63.88,
          "10B": 63.88,
          "11B": 9.35
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F39",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 63.88,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 63.88,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 63.88,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 63.88,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 63.88,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/glacier-lily-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Glacier%20Lily%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-05-24"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "golden-hour",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Golden Hour",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/golden-hour-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 5.8,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 5.8%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 5.8,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 5.8%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 24.3,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 24.3%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Golden%20Hour%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2023-12-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 24.3,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 5.8,
          "10B": 18.4,
          "11B": 0.6
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F40",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.8,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.8,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 5.8,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 5.8,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.8,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 5.8,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 5.8,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 24.3,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 24.3,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 24.3,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 24.3,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.8,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/golden-hour-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Golden%20Hour%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2023-12-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "green-leaves-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Green Leaves Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/green-leaves-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Green%20Leaves%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 2.24,
          "4": 40,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 4.32,
          "9": 78.4,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 10.24,
          "5B": 10.24,
          "5C": 10.24,
          "5D": 10.24,
          "7A": 83.2,
          "7B": 83.2,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 100,
          "11B": 100
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F41",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 40,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 40,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/green-leaves-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Green%20Leaves%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "honey-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Honey Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/honey-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Honey%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2025-07-11",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 1.5,
          "4": 28.14,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 2.94,
          "9": 54.97,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 7.19,
          "5B": 7.19,
          "5C": 7.19,
          "5D": 7.19,
          "7A": 57.59,
          "7B": 57.59,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 80,
          "11B": 80
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F42",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 28.14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 28.14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/honey-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Honey%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-07-11"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "jalapeno-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Jalapeño Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/jalapeno-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 10.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Jalapeno-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2026-05-05",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 20.8,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.67,
          "9": 10.4,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 24.8,
          "5B": 2,
          "5C": 3.04,
          "5D": 0.67,
          "7A": 2.48,
          "7B": 2.48,
          "10A": 10.4,
          "10B": 22.4,
          "11A": 0.67,
          "11B": 0.67
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F43",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 5,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 5,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 22.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.4,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": 5,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 10,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/jalapeno-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Jalapeno-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-05-05"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "jasmine-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Jasmine Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/jasmine-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Jasmine%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2025-09-04",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 60.53,
          "2": 18.83,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 43.33,
          "8": 28.25,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 86.09,
          "5B": 83.33,
          "5C": 83.33,
          "5D": 28.25,
          "7A": 83.33,
          "7B": 83.33,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 28.25,
          "11B": 28.25
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F44",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/jasmine-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Jasmine%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-09-04"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "labdanum-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Labdanum Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/labdanum-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 12,
          "sourceText": "up to 12.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Labdanum%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2025-07-11",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 1.33,
          "4": 25.01,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.81,
          "9": 12.13,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 6.39,
          "5B": 2.56,
          "5C": 3.73,
          "5D": 0.81,
          "7A": 4.2,
          "7B": 4.2,
          "10A": 12.13,
          "10B": 37.33,
          "11A": 0.81,
          "11B": 0.81
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F45",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 12.13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 12,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 12,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 37.33,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 12.13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 12.13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25.01,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25.01,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 12.13,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 12,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/labdanum-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Labdanum%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-07-11"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "leather",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Leather",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/leather-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 2.2,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 2.2%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2.2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.2%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Leather%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-19",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 5.57,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 2.2,
          "10B": 13.94,
          "11B": 0.08
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F46",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13.94,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.2,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.2% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.2,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.2% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.57,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.57,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.2,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/leather-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Leather%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-19"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "leather-and-labdanum",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Leather and Labdanum",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/leather-and-labdanum-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Leather%20and%20Labdanum%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2024-03-11",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 25.01,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 33.6,
          "10B": 92.4,
          "11B": 2.66
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F47",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 92.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25.01,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25.01,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.6,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/leather-and-labdanum-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Leather%20and%20Labdanum%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-03-11"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "lemon-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Lemon Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/lemon-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 2.7,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 2.7%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2.7,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.7%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 9.7,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 9.7%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Lemon%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 0.07,
          "4": 1.39,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.11,
          "9": 2.78,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 0.34,
          "5B": 0.34,
          "5C": 0.34,
          "5D": 0.11,
          "7A": 0.46,
          "7B": 0.46,
          "10A": 2.78,
          "10B": 9.75,
          "11A": 0.11,
          "11B": 0.11
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F48",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.78,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 9.7,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 9.7,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.78,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.78,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.78% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.78,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.78,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.78% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 1.39,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 1.39,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.78,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/lemon-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Lemon%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "library",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Library",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/library-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Library%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-20",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 57.21,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11B": 100
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F49",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 57.21,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 57.21,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/library-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Library%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-20"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "mineral-drift",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Mineral Drift",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/mineral-drift-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 14.73,
          "sourceText": "up to 14.73%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Mineral%20Drift%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2025-10-30",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 36.28,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 14.73,
          "10B": 31.73,
          "11B": 0.95
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F50",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.73,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 14.73,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 14.73,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 31.73,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.73,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.73,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 36.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 36.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.73,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 14.73,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/mineral-drift-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Mineral%20Drift%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-10-30"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "moss-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Moss Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/moss-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Moss%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 6.55,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 11.66,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 30.89,
          "5B": 30.89,
          "5C": 30.89,
          "5D": 11.66,
          "7A": 35.47,
          "7B": 35.47,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 11.66,
          "11B": 11.66
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F51",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/moss-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Moss%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "muguet-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Muguet Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/muguet-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 13.1,
          "sourceText": "up to 13.1%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Muguet%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 5.43,
          "4": 54.29,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 1.42,
          "9": 13.14,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 25.71,
          "5B": 4.34,
          "5C": 4.34,
          "5D": 1.42,
          "7A": 4.34,
          "7B": 4.34,
          "10A": 13.14,
          "10B": 41.15,
          "11A": 1.42,
          "11B": 1.42
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F52",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13.14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 13.1,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 13.1,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 41.15,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13.14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13.14,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 54.29,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 54.29,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13.14,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 13.1,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/muguet-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Muguet%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "nocturna",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Nocturna",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/nocturna-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Nocturna%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2026-04-27",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 83.19,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 7.64,
          "10B": 16.47,
          "11B": 0.49
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F53",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.64,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 16.47,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.64,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.64,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.64,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.64,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.64,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.64,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 83.19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 83.19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.64,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/nocturna-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Nocturna%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-04-27"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "orange-blossom-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Orange Blossom Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/orange-blossom-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Orange-Blossom-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2026-05-05",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 4.56,
          "4": 85.36,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 8.93,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 21.83,
          "5B": 21.83,
          "5C": 21.83,
          "5D": 21.83,
          "7A": 100,
          "7B": 99.28,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 99.28,
          "11A": 38,
          "11B": 38
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F54",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 99.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 99.28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 85.36,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 85.36,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 5,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 5,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/orange-blossom-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Orange-Blossom-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-05-05"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ozonic-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Ozonic Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/ozonic-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 5.7,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 5.7%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 5.7,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 5.7%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 23.7,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 23.7%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Ozonic%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 3.5,
          "4": 23.75,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.62,
          "9": 5.75,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 11.25,
          "5B": 1.9,
          "5C": 1.9,
          "5D": 0.62,
          "7A": 1.9,
          "7B": 1.9,
          "10A": 5.75,
          "10B": 18,
          "11A": 0.62,
          "11B": 0.62
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F55",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 18,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 5.75,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 5.75,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 5.75,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 5.75,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 23.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 23.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 23.7,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 23.7,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.75,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/ozonic-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Ozonic%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "paloma",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Paloma",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/paloma-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 11.1,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 11.1%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 22.3,
          "sourceText": "up to 22.3%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Paloma%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-21",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 11.17,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 22.34,
          "10B": 78.2,
          "11B": 0.94
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F56",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 22.34,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 22.3,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 22.3,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 78.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 22.34,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 22.34,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 11.17,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 11.1,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 11.1,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 11.17,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 11.1,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 11.1% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 22.34,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 22.3,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/paloma-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Paloma%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-21"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "peppermint-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Peppermint Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/peppermint-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 19,
          "sourceText": "up to 19.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Peppermint-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2026-05-05",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 11.83,
          "4": 48,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.7,
          "9": 19,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 43,
          "5B": 2.1,
          "5C": 8.3,
          "5D": 0.7,
          "7A": 4.1,
          "7B": 4.1,
          "10A": 19,
          "10B": 50.22,
          "11A": 0.7,
          "11B": 0.7
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F57",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 19,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 19,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 50.22,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 19,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/peppermint-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Peppermint-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-05-05"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "pine-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Pine Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/pine-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Pine%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-12-09",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 6.22,
          "4": 36.36,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 1.63,
          "9": 36.36,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 28.44,
          "5B": 5.09,
          "5C": 9.81,
          "5D": 1.63,
          "7A": 14.9,
          "7B": 14.9,
          "10A": 36.36,
          "10B": 36.36,
          "11A": 1.63,
          "11B": 1.63
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F58",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 36.36,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 36.36,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 36.36,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 36.36,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 36.36,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 36.36,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 36.36,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/pine-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Pine%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-12-09"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "pineapple-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Pineapple Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/pineapple-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Pineapple%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 17.93,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 2.48,
          "9": 67.38,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 82,
          "5B": 7.44,
          "5C": 29.43,
          "5D": 2.48,
          "7A": 14.54,
          "7B": 14.54,
          "10A": 67.38,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 2.48,
          "11B": 2.48
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F59",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 67.38,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 67.38,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 67.38,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 67.38,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/pineapple-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Pineapple%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "pink-grapefruit-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Pink Grapefruit Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/pink-grapefruit-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Pink%20Grapefruit%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 1.75,
          "4": 32.9,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 2.8,
          "9": 64.4,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 8.4,
          "5B": 8.4,
          "5C": 8.4,
          "5D": 2.8,
          "7A": 20.76,
          "7B": 20.76,
          "10A": 49,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 2.8,
          "11B": 2.8
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F60",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 49,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 49,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 49,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 32.9,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 32.9,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 49,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/pink-grapefruit-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Pink%20Grapefruit%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "praline-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Praline Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/praline-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 19.2,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 19.2%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Praline%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 2.38,
          "4": 19.2,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.28,
          "9": 7.6,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 10.88,
          "5B": 0.84,
          "5C": 3.32,
          "5D": 0.28,
          "7A": 1.64,
          "7B": 1.64,
          "10A": 7.6,
          "10B": 48.01,
          "11A": 0.28,
          "11B": 0.28
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F61",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48.01,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.6,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.6,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.6,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.6,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 19.2,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 19.2% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.6,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/praline-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Praline%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "pumpkin-spice-buttercream",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Pumpkin Spice Buttercream",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/pumpkin-spice-buttercream-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 2.1,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 2.1%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2.1,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.1%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 7.9,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 7.9%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Pumpkin%20Spice%20Buttercream%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-18",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 1.1,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 2.16,
          "10B": 7.96,
          "11B": 0.06
        }
      },
      "notes": [
        "IFRA 10A 2.16% is below EcoBase Room and Linen Spray calculator's published 3% starting range; combined room+linen standard recipe has no overlap."
      ],
      "referenceId": "F62",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.16,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.96,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.9,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.9,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.16,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.16,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.16% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.16,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.16,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.16% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 1.1,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 1.1,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.16,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/pumpkin-spice-buttercream-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Pumpkin%20Spice%20Buttercream%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-18"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "rose-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Rose Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/rose-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Rose%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2025-07-11",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 11.94,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 19.58,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 57.05,
          "5B": 57.05,
          "5C": 57.05,
          "5D": 19.58,
          "7A": 100,
          "7B": 100,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 19.58,
          "11B": 19.58
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F63",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/rose-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Rose%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-07-11"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "sage-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Sage Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sage-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 19.97,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 19.97%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Sage-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2026-08-07",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 1.06,
          "4": 19.97,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 1.23,
          "9": 33.42,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 4.99,
          "5B": 3.69,
          "5C": 4.99,
          "5D": 1.23,
          "7A": 6.65,
          "7B": 6.65,
          "10A": 33.42,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 1.23,
          "11B": 1.23
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F64",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.42,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.42,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.42,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19.97,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19.97,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 19.97,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 19.97% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.42,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sage-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS-Sage-Element-IFRA-51.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-08-07"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "sandalwood-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Sandalwood Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sandalwood-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Sandalwood%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 8.85,
          "4": 100,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 17.14,
          "9": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 41.43,
          "5B": 41.43,
          "5C": 41.43,
          "5D": 25.33,
          "7A": 89.33,
          "7B": 89.33,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 25.33,
          "11B": 25.33
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F65",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sandalwood-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Sandalwood%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "santal-and-coconut",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Santal and Coconut",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/santal-and-coconut-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 14.9,
          "sourceText": "up to 14.9%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Santal%20and%20Coconut%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-19",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 72.3,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 14.93,
          "10B": 41.06,
          "11B": 1.17
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F66",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.93,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 14.9,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 14.9,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 41.06,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.93,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.93,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 72.3,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 72.3,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.93,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 14.9,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/santal-and-coconut-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Santal%20and%20Coconut%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-19"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "sea-salt-and-orchid",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Sea Salt and Orchid",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sea-salt-and-orchid-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Sea%20Salt%20and%20Orchid%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-18",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 30.67,
          "10B": 96.01,
          "11B": 3.33
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F67",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 30.67,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 96.01,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 30.67,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 30.67,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 30.67,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sea-salt-and-orchid-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Sea%20Salt%20and%20Orchid%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-18"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "sirocco",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Sirocco",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sirocco-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Sirocco%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2026-04-27",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 9.62,
          "10B": 20.74,
          "11B": 0.62
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F68",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.62,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 20.74,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.62,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 9.62,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 9.62,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.62,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 9.62,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 9.62,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 9.62,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sirocco-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Sirocco%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-04-27"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "smoke-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Smoke Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/smoke-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Smoke%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 5.48,
          "4": 97.98,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 8.23,
          "9": 98,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 25.08,
          "5B": 25.08,
          "5C": 25.08,
          "5D": 8.23,
          "7A": 29.89,
          "7B": 29.89,
          "10A": 29.89,
          "10B": 100,
          "11A": 8.23,
          "11B": 8.23
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F69",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 29.89,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 29.89,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 29.89,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 97.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 97.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 29.89,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/smoke-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Smoke%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "solace",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Solace",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/solace-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 13,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 13.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Solace%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2026-04-27",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 59.98,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 13,
          "10B": 28,
          "11B": 0.84
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F70",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 13,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 13,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 28,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 59.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 59.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 13,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": 10,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 13,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/solace-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Solace%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-04-27"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "solaia",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Solaia",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/solaia-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 5,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 5.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Solaia%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2026-04-27",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 53.35,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 78.39,
          "10B": 100,
          "11B": 9.84
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F71",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 78.39,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 78.39,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 78.39,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 53.35,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 53.35,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 78.39,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": 10,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/solaia-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Solaia%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-04-27"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "strawberry-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Strawberry Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/strawberry-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Strawberry%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 1.76,
          "4": 33.11,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 2.88,
          "9": 64.5,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 8.6,
          "5B": 8.6,
          "5C": 8.6,
          "5D": 2.88,
          "7A": 35.26,
          "7B": 35.26,
          "10A": 86,
          "10B": 86,
          "11A": 2.88,
          "11B": 2.88
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F72",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 86,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 86,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 86,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 86,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.11,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.11,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 86,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/strawberry-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Strawberry%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "sunwashed",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Sunwashed",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sunwashed-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Sunwashed%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2023-12-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 33.6,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 25.4,
          "10B": 33.6,
          "11B": 2.3
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F73",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25.4,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 33.6,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 25.4,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sunwashed-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Sunwashed%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2023-12-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "sweet-tobacco",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Sweet Tobacco",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sweet-tobacco-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 3,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 3.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 3,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 3.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 3,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 3.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Sweet%20Tobacco%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-19",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 3.09,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 3.09,
          "10B": 3.09,
          "11B": 0.87
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F74",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.09,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.09,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 3,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 3,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.09,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 3,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 3,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.09,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 3,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 3,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.09,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.09,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 3.09,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/sweet-tobacco-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Sweet%20Tobacco%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-19"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "tideglass",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Tideglass",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/tideglass-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Tideglass%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2026-04-27",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 100,
          "10B": 100,
          "11B": 7.07
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F75",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": 10,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/tideglass-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Tideglass%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-04-27"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "tomato-vine-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Tomato Vine Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/tomato-vine-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 1.9,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 1.9%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 19,
          "sourceText": "up to 19.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Tomato%20Vine%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2025-07-11",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 0.4,
          "4": 7.69,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.66,
          "9": 14.99,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 1.99,
          "5B": 1.99,
          "5C": 1.99,
          "5D": 0.66,
          "7A": 4.1,
          "7B": 4.1,
          "10A": 19,
          "10B": 53.98,
          "11A": 0.66,
          "11B": 0.66
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F76",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 19,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 19,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 53.98,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.69,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.69,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 19,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/tomato-vine-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Tomato%20Vine%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-07-11"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "vanilla-element",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Vanilla Element",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/vanilla-element-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 19.5,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 19.5%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Vanilla%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "51 in the current linked certificate filename",
        "preparedDate": "2024-07-22",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "1": 0,
          "2": 5.33,
          "4": 19.59,
          "6": 0,
          "8": 0.28,
          "9": 7.75,
          "12": 100,
          "5A": 17.55,
          "5B": 0.85,
          "5C": 3.38,
          "5D": 0.28,
          "7A": 1.67,
          "7B": 1.67,
          "10A": 7.75,
          "10B": 48.97,
          "11A": 0.28,
          "11B": 0.28
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F77",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 48.97,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.75,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.75,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 7.75,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 7.75,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19.59,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 19.59,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 19.5,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 19.5% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 7.75,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/vanilla-element-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Vanilla%20Element%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2024-07-22"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "vanilla-orchid",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Vanilla Orchid",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/vanilla-orchid-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 4.2,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 4.2%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 4.2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 4.2%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 10.7,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 10.7%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Vanilla%20Orchid%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-09-04",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 10.75,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 4.25,
          "10B": 26.88,
          "11B": 0.15
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F78",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.25,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 26.88,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.25,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 4.25,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 4.25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.25,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 4.25,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 4.25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10.7,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10.7,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 10.75,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10.7,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 10.7% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 4.25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/vanilla-orchid-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Vanilla%20Orchid%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-09-04"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "whiskey",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "Whiskey",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/whiskey-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 2.3,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 2.3%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2.3,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.3%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": false,
          "minPercent": 0,
          "maxPercent": 0,
          "sourceText": "0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Whiskey%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Linked certificate filename identifies IFRA 51.",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-19",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 5.89,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 2.33,
          "10B": 14.74,
          "11B": 0.08
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F79",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.33,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 0,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 14.74,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.33,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.33,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.33% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.33,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 2.33,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 2.33% is below the 3% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.89,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "notRecommended",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 5.89,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 0,
          "workingMinPercent": 0,
          "workingMaxPercent": 0,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": "Supplier explicitly marks this application not approved (0%). This is not a claim that the IFRA category limit is zero."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 2.33,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "notRecommended",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": null,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/whiskey-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20Whiskey%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-19"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "white-sage-and-lavender",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "White Sage and Lavender",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/white-sage-and-lavender-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20White%20Sage%20and%20Lavender%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2026-03-25",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 100,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 43.12,
          "10B": 100,
          "11B": 2.9
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F80",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 43.12,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 43.12,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 43.12,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": 20,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 43.12,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/white-sage-and-lavender-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20White%20Sage%20and%20Lavender%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2026-03-25"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "white-tea",
      "supplier": "CandleScience",
      "name": "White Tea",
      "productUrl": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/white-tea-fragrance-oil/",
      "verifiedDate": "2026-10-29",
      "supplierRecommendations": {
        "candles": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 3,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "3.0% - 10.0%"
        },
        "waxMelts": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 5,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "5.0% - 25.0%"
        },
        "barSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 2,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "2.0% - 6.0%"
        },
        "liquidSoap": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 6,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 6.0%"
        },
        "lotion": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 2,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 2.0%"
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 0.5,
          "maxPercent": 10,
          "sourceText": "0.5% - 10.0%"
        },
        "perfume": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": 10,
          "maxPercent": 17.2,
          "sourceText": "10.0% - 17.2%"
        },
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "supplierApproved": true,
          "minPercent": null,
          "maxPercent": 25,
          "sourceText": "up to 25.0%"
        }
      },
      "ifra": {
        "certificateUrl": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20White%20Tea%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
        "amendment": 51,
        "amendmentEvidence": "Actual linked certificate filename contains IFRA 51",
        "preparedDate": "2025-08-16",
        "maxUsagePercent": {
          "4": 17.2,
          "12": 100,
          "10A": 38.21,
          "10B": 100,
          "11B": 2.27
        }
      },
      "notes": [],
      "referenceId": "F81",
      "usages": {
        "reedDiffuser": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 38.21,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "reedDiffuser",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 25,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": 25,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "roomSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "linenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 38.21,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": "Derived using the supplier room-spray recommendation, this room/linen base and textile-spray IFRA 10A; not a separate supplier per-oil linen test."
        },
        "roomAndLinenSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseRoomLinenConcentrate",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A",
            "10B"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 38.21,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "roomSpray",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeSpray": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseFineFragranceWater",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 17.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 10,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 15,
          "workingMinPercent": 10,
          "workingMaxPercent": 15,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "perfumeOil": {
          "status": "belowStandardRange",
          "baseId": "ecoBasePerfumeOil",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "4"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 17.2,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "perfume",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 20,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 17.2,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "ifra"
          ],
          "reason": "Ceiling 17.2% is below the 20% lower bound of the intersected normal ranges. Lower-strength development may be possible; no normal-range formula is supplied."
        },
        "containerCandle": {
          "status": "workingRange",
          "baseId": "simplySoyArtisanContainer",
          "percentBasis": "waxWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "supplierApplicationKey": "candles",
          "normalRangeMinPercent": 3,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": 10,
          "workingMinPercent": 3,
          "workingMaxPercent": 10,
          "limitingFactors": [
            "supplierRecommendation",
            "baseNormalMaximum"
          ],
          "reason": null
        },
        "solidCarFreshener": {
          "status": "unverified",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "noVerifiedRecipe",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "12"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 100,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reason": "No official felt-specific rate verified. Category 12 is recorded only as an exposure ceiling for a solid non-aerosol non-skin-contact product. Reed approval is not a felt approval or ban. Confirm substrate, carrier, dose and performance."
        },
        "liquidCarDiffuser": {
          "status": "testOnly",
          "baseId": "ecoBaseReedDiffuser",
          "percentBasis": "finishedProductWeight",
          "ifraCategories": [
            "10A"
          ],
          "ifraMaxPercentFinishedProduct": 38.21,
          "workingMinPercent": null,
          "workingMaxPercent": null,
          "screeningCeilingPercent": null,
          "manufacturerCarRecipeAvailable": false,
          "reedFormulationScreen": "workingRange",
          "referenceReedMinPercent": null,
          "referenceReedMaxPercent": 25,
          "reason": "No official hanging-car-bottle rate verified. A reed-compatible blend is an R&D candidate only for open/refillable liquid hardware; materials, leakage, heat and evaporation need testing. IFRA 10A is the working classification for this format, not all car devices."
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierProductPage",
          "url": "https://www.candlescience.com/fragrance/white-tea-fragrance-oil/",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29"
        },
        {
          "sourceType": "supplierIfraCertificate",
          "url": "https://dpoy1j4zladj1.cloudfront.net/CS%20White%20Tea%20IFRA%2051.pdf",
          "accessedDate": "2026-10-29",
          "preparedDate": "2025-08-16"
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "methodology": {
    "percentUnit": "percentagePoints",
    "numberExample": "25 means 25%, not 0.25.",
    "liquidPercentBasis": "Oil mass / total finished liquid mass x 100. Includes water in diluted sprays.",
    "candlePercentBasis": "Oil mass / wax mass x 100.",
    "candleToFinishedPercentFormula": "100 * waxLoadPercent / (100 + waxLoadPercent)",
    "ifraToWaxLoadPercentFormula": "100 * ifraMaxPercent / (100 - ifraMaxPercent); 100% IFRA means no finite IFRA-derived wax cap.",
    "workingRangeMethod": "Intersect supplier application range, chosen base normal range and applicable IFRA ceiling; preserve all original fields. For supplier up-to wording, do not invent a minimum.",
    "sourcePriority": "Retain conflicting source values and use the lower applicable limit in the derived working range. Explicit supplier non-approval stays 0 despite positive IFRA permission.",
    "linenCategory": "10A for ordinary fabric/textile spray; a product labeled for room and linen must satisfy both 10A and 10B. Pillow sprays require their own 11B check.",
    "perfumeCategory": "4 for localized personal fragrance. Not body spray, hair mist or all-over body oil.",
    "carClassification": "12 for solid non-aerosol air care; 10A used as a working classification for open/refillable liquid car bottles. No car-specific rate is established.",
    "blends": "Ranges apply to each purchased oil used on its own. They do not certify a custom blend. Shared restricted ingredients require aggregate assessment; use supplier blend guidance and test the finished product.",
    "rounding": "Never round a limiting percentage upward. Preserve published precision."
  },
  "displayLegend": {
    "0": "Explicit supplier non-approval (or actual zero IFRA where stated).",
    "LOW <= x%": "No overlap with the base normal band; x is a ceiling, not a recommended formula.",
    "TEST": "No verified car recipe; development required.",
    "NA": "Unknown or not applicable, never substitute a numeric zero."
  }
}